A slice of tradition and innovation that has been a beloved part of the Lakeville and Geneseo, NY communities since 1993. Founded by the dynamic duo, Paul and Catherine Miller, our pizzeria has a rich legacy that spans generations.
Paul Miller, a pizza maestro with a career dating back to 1969, is a well-known name in our community. His dedication to perfecting the art of pizza-making has been passed on to his daughter Teresa and her husband Craig which is evident in every mouthwatering slice we serve.
Our commitment to quality and authenticity runs deep, passed down through the years. We take pride in being a place where friends and families gather to share not only incredible food but also memorable moments.
At Pizza Paul's, we don't just serve pizza; we serve community, tradition, and a slice of home. Our goal is to continue being a place where everyone feels welcome, whether you're enjoying a timeless classic or trying one of our innovative creations.
Our menu is a testament to our passion for innovation. While we hold dear to the classics that have made us a local favorite, we're always eager to push the boundaries of pizza creativity. Our unique menu items, like the Subzone, reflect our desire to surprise and delight your taste buds with every visit.
See our menu
.jpeg)
Subscribe to receive special offers, exclusive event invitations, and more!
Authentic NY style experience! Absolutely delicious food and fantastic service! Don't forget to try the cheese cake balls!
We ordered for the first time and it’s very very very delicious and we will be going back. I got the pickle pizza and fried mushrooms.
I ordered a large thin crust pizza and it was fabulous. We also ordered some boneless wings and they were great too. Staff was nice also I would recommend to anyone.
Been here every 4th of July week for literally decades. Consistently good pizza. Good crust, lots of toppings. Will visit again next year as always a family tradition.
5808 Big Tree Street, Lakeville, NY 14480
Sunday - Thursday:
11:00 am - 9:00 pm
Friday - Saturday:
11:00 am - 10:00 pm
110 Main Street, Geneseo, NY 14454
Sunday - Thursday:
11:00 am - 9:00 pm
Friday - Saturday:
11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Do you have any comments about our menu, or do you want to reserve a spot for a private party? Please fill the form down below and we'll respond ASAP.
%20(2).png)